Island News & Views
Go to Site Index See "Island News & Views" main page
General · 15th January 2009
Allen Perkins
We all want Quadra to breathe easier, but we'll need to address some old habits and misconceptions as we gear up our anti-idling campaign. Let's "clear the air" so we can clear the air.
It is commonly believed that vehicles have to idle for several minutes before driving for maximum efficiency. That used to be accurate, but today's engines only need a few seconds of idling before they can be driven safely. The driving itself completes the job, because it warms up the engine, the catalytic converter and the other mechanical parts of your vehicle. Diesel engines can only be warmed up by driving.
In sub-freezing weather, using a block heater will warm your engine faster and improve your mileage.
It's also widely held that constant stopping and starting your vehicle wastes more gas than idling. Actually, you're better off shutting down if you've idled more than 60 seconds, except in traffic. Engines don't operate effectively at rest.
A related misbelief is that repeated restarting of your car or truck is rough on the engine and quickly drains the battery. That used to be the case, but newer vehicles have electronic ignitions and stronger batteries that tolerate it well. In fact, idling makes your engine run in a gas-rich mode that can eventually degrade its performance and reduce mileage.
Idling is also used as a reason to run the defroster. Although you wouldn't want to drive until you could see clearly, you can minimize idling by using a small ice scraper and cracking a window to vent out moisture.
Winter is the hardest time to address the issue of idling because we want to keep warm and safe. But if we start now, the rest of the year will be a breeze -- an easier-to-breathe breeze.
CLEARIING THE AIR ABOUT VEHICLE IDLING
Comment by Al Beattie on 21st January 2009
I agree with the first two comments. The third one bothers me because it represents the thinking of many people.
Sorry buddy, it is an accumulation of all the little and the big things that make a difference in our environment. Denying or comparing only enable self-serving behaviors.
Regarding ferry idling; we have a very comfortable, warm new waiting room on our side. Shut your vehicle off and wait there.
Thank you!
Comment by Gypsy Mama on 16th January 2009
Yes, idling is definitely something that needs to be addressed here on Quadra and everywhere. However can we make changes in the large cities? Yes, by walking our talk, others will follow: that is walk when possible, pick up hitch-hikers when driving and turn off the vehicle whenever stopped for more than one minute. Often enough I've been in a ferry line up on Quadra and Cortes behind an idling vehicle and even during this short interval my air quality is affected. So, yes, please do your part and turn it off, EACH OF US DOING ONE LITTLE BIT MAKES A DIFFERENCE!
Exceptions
Comment by Lynden on 15th January 2009
The previous comment holds true in almost all typical driving scenarios here on our fair island, with the one big exeption...
The ferry parking lot.

People are constantly idling away for no good reason other than to maintain that constant perfect temperature inside their car.
Get over it! So what if the temp drops a couple of degrees while you're waiting.
You'll live.
Basic issues first
Comment by Al Longdon on 15th January 2009
Before we get upset about how best to fix a bathtub leak, don't we want to know how much its leaking?

How much time is spent idling per hour of driving?

In a big city with congested traffic, traffic lights, accidents, main routes blocked during rush hour and so on, the idle time could be significant.

But Quadra Island????

Unless you deliberatly leave your car running under silly conditions, the answer is almost zero.

So if we get super good at reducing zero, how much have we saved?

If we really want to fuss about this maybe it would help to go back and do it in Vancouver?

I suspect the rest of us have better things to do.